Skip to main content

The J Curve explained

In order to make sense of the seemingly conflicting reports about wine and health there’s one essential thing to understand: the J-shaped curve. It’s a simple concept, universal, in plain sight, and often ignored. It goes like this: Take “nondrinking” as the baseline and plot increased or decreased relative risk of a health issue with increasing levels of daily consumption. Nondrinkers have a certain risk of, say heart attacks, moderate drinkers a lower risk, heavy drinkers a relatively higher risk. Not too complicated. The tricky parts are separating wine drinkers from drinkers in general, and daily moderate drinkers from occasional drinkers.

The J-curve is not just about wine

The J-shaped curve is too universal to ignore once you see it. Even dietary salt intake has a J-curve; consuming too little in your diet can be as harmful as too much. For years, the American Heart Association has endorsed a 1.5 gram per day limit on sodium intake (salt is about 40% sodium), about what you get in a 6-inch sub sandwich or a bowl of vegetable soup. However, a massive multi-country review a couple of years ago found that the lowest incidence of heart disease correlated to about 4-5 grams per day, the bottom of a J-curve. Similar patterns plot out for coffee, vitamins, even water.
Wait - water? Obviously not drinking enough water is unhealthy, and questioning the benefits of hydration seems a fool’s errand. But it is possible to take it too far; in 2007 a woman participating in a water drinking contest called “Hold Your Wee for a Wii” was found dead of water intoxication. Superhydration throws electrolyte balances out of whack, with toxic and even fatal levels of water intake surprisingly easy to achieve. A  J-shaped curve.
Even lifetime happiness reportedly follows the curve. Young people generally enjoy a sense of well-being and optimism, career and family stress creates a dip through the 20’s and 30’s, then later in life happiness rises above the baseline, at least for most.

Why the J-curve is sometimes overlooked

Why is this simple model so often overlooked? One reason is that good data points are hard to come by, when it is drinking and eating habits that are being tabulated. People are unreliable self-reporters. Or researchers may have hidden agendas based on the need to publish, so that they focus on only the findings that support their hypothesis. Research on breast cancer and alcohol is particularly fraught with this problem; heavy drinking is unquestionably bad, but difficult in parsing out the subset of women who drink red wine (for example) with regularity and in moderation leads to extrapolation errors. If you simply draw a line from the heavy drinking/high risk corner of the graph down to the no drinking corner, you miss the bottom of the J. And you don’t want to miss the bottom of the J curve.


  1. Unfortunately they totally miss a potent confounder. Non drinkers include sick people who have given up alchohol due to poor hhealth; therefore the non drinkers include them also and the statistics become skewed in favor of drinkers.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The J-curve is dead. Long live the J-curve!

There is a resurgence of debate about the validity of the J-curve, especially as it relates to alcohol and cancer. A 2014 report determined that “alcohol use was positively associated with overall mortality, alcohol-related cancers, and violent death and injuries, but marginally to CVD/CHD” (cardiovascular disease). In other words, there was little benefit if any in terms of heart disease but a big upside risk for cancer and accidental or violent demise. Gone was the French Paradox! The J curve is dead! Or not. Though that statement may be technically true, I looked at look at the data myself and found something different: a strong confirmation of the J-curve for overall mortality, overall cancer deaths, cardiovascular disease, and all “other causes.” This held for both men and women:
    Used under creative commons license from Ferrari P, Licaj I,Muller DC, et al. Lifetime alcohol use and overall and cause-specific mortality in the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and nu…

Which types of wine are the healthiest?

I am often asked after lecturing on the healthful properties of wine which type is best to drink. Since much of the discussion has to do with the polyphenol antioxidants from the skins and seeds of the grape, red wine is the first criterion since it is fermented with the whole grape rather than the pressed juice. This allows for extraction and concentration of these compounds, familiar ones being resveratrol and tannins. But beyond that, which varietals have the highest concentrations?

According to the Roman philosopher Pliny the Elder, “The best kind of wine is that which is pleasant to him that drinks it” but modern science expects more specifics. (The point of course is that if you have a wine that you enjoy you are more likely to drink regularly and therefore reap the benefits.) But there are several difficulties in singling out certain wines for their healthful properties. Which compounds to measure? Are we talking about heart health or the whole gamut? Is it the varietal of the …

Is wine a probiotic? More than a gut feeling

That “gut feeling” you sometimes get may be more literal than you think: research continues to reveal the importance of the bacteria in our digestive tract, called the “gut microbiome.”  This symbiotic population of microbes affects health and well-being in often unexpected ways. The microbiome sends signals to the central nervous system, regulates inflammation, even influences cardiovascular health. Wine’s impact on health appears to depend significantly on the microbiome, and we are now learning that it may not actually be the constituents of wine that make it healthy for us; it is the things that the microbiome transforms them into. How wine promotes a healthy microbiome Wine’s relationship with the microbiome is a two-way street: Recent studies[1]  demonstrate how wine consumption influences the composition of the various bacteria, while other research demonstrates how the microbiome metabolizes wine into components that boost the immune system.[2] The idea that wine’s health be…